Six Keepers to Pick. WHIR.

[toledomudhens]

I need help deciding on who to keep. Will help in return, just leave the link.
I play in a ten team, H2H, yahoo league that keeps 6 players.

Cats are...
Batters - R,RBI,HR,SB,AVG,OPS
Pitchers - ERA,K,S,WHIP,BB/9,QS

You are allowed to keep:
2 players that you drafted between rounds 1-5
2 players that you drafted between rounds 6-10
2 players that you drafted between rounds 11-23

An owner is not required to keep players from any round. You can sacrifice a higher round pick for a lower round pick. For example, an owner could keep 4 players from rounds 6-10 if the owner gave up keeping all of his 1-5 picks. This allows us to keeper players that have a greater keeper value.

The round the player would cost me is in ().

Here's my roster:

Erick Aybar(16)
Jose Bautista(2)
Pedro Ciriaco(23)
Allen Craig(23)
Paul Goldschmidt(17)
Carlos Gomez(23)
Curtis Granderson(10)
Torii Hunter(23)
Austin Jackson(23)
Brett Lawrie(22)
Buster Posey(8)
Mike Trout(15)
Joey Votto(1)

Pitchers
Homer Bailey(23)
Johnny Cueto(12)
Marco Estrada(23)
Roy Halladay(1)
Steve Johnson(23)
Clayton Kershaw(1)
Ricky Nolasco(23)
Andy Pettitte(23)
Stephen Strasburg(17)
Chris Tillman(23)
Justin Verlander(4)

To me the locks are...
Mike Trout(15)
Buster Posey(8)
Stephen Strasburg(17)

After that I am less decided. To me the following all need to be considered.
Allen Craig(23)
Paul Goldschmidt(17)
Curtis Granderson(10)
Brett Lawrie(22)
Justin Verlander(4)

What six do I keep? THANKS! ...and WHIR

Ok so there are my six, votto is a first rounder no doubt about it, then verlander for a 4th round is tremendous value, way more then kershaw for a 1st, I think the last 4 are easy choices as well. You have some real value in players like stras and trout, but craig at 23 is a real bargin, way better than goldie at 17 in my opinon....good luck

[kslates]

Can you keep Goldschmidt, Trout, & Strasburg if you only keep 1 in rd 6-10? I think from reading your original post you can. If so, I'd do that plus Verlander, Bautista & Posey


Help me?
viewtopic.php?t=454715

[toledomudhens]

ok I read that wrong
1-5 votto,verlander
6-10 posey, granderson
11-23 trout, strasburg
Sorry about that....that would be the way i would go...posey and votto and trout would totally make up for grandersons short comings in avg.....

[Brainstorm]

To me its...

Votto (1)
Verlander (4)

Posey (8)

Trout (15)
Goldschmidt (17)
Strasburg (17)

I don't mind losing the opportunity to keep Granderson for a 10th, when Goldschmidt at 17(or 16 if you go up a round since Stras is a 17th too) is a better value.

[toledomudhens]

Im sorry but the possibility of 100-38-110-10-.240, is definitly worth a 10th rounder, yes his avg is brutal, but how could u discount what the guy has done the previous 2 seasons, especially over goldy who might get better...lawrie and hosmer were supposed to be awsome as well following there rookie seasons. Grandy in the 10th is a no brainer in my mind, especially with all the awsome AVG he has.

[exm]

ok I read that wrong
1-5 votto,verlander
6-10 posey, granderson
11-23 trout, strasburg
Sorry about that....that would be the way i would go...posey and votto and trout would totally make up for grandersons short comings in avg.....

OP... Thanks for helping. I agree with the above ^

[Brainstorm]

Im sorry but the possibility of 100-38-110-10-.240, is definitly worth a 10th rounder, yes his avg is brutal, but how could u discount what the guy has done the previous 2 seasons, especially over goldy who might get better...lawrie and hosmer were supposed to be awsome as well following there rookie seasons. Grandy in the 10th is a no brainer in my mind, especially with all the awsome AVG he has.

Sure, def worth a 10th rounder, but the production I'm expecting to get from a 17th rounder in Goldschmidt can exceed him value wise. That's no discredit to Granderson and the value he brings. It's certainly a tough decision though.

[toledomudhens]

Im sorry but the possibility of 100-38-110-10-.240, is definitly worth a 10th rounder, yes his avg is brutal, but how could u discount what the guy has done the previous 2 seasons, especially over goldy who might get better...lawrie and hosmer were supposed to be awsome as well following there rookie seasons. Grandy in the 10th is a no brainer in my mind, especially with all the awsome AVG he has.

Sure, def worth a 10th rounder, but the production I'm expecting to get from a 17th rounder in Goldschmidt can exceed him value wise. That's no discredit to Granderson and the value he brings. It's certainly a tough decision though.

See thats why I say grandy, because your saying your expecting goldy to do something.But granderson is doing it, year after year...100-35ish-110-240ish-10....almost guarenteed, I have no doubt goldy is going to be good, just not that good yet, and a 10 round for those #s is awsome value...in my opionin....