I think Encarnacion win hands down.
Encarnacion is the best name on the list.........and the next best players are 5 pitchers (Darvish Gonzalez, Gallard, Medlen and Kimbrel).....and Encarnacion is significantly better than the other hitters on the list (Bourn, Trumbo and Desmond)
Rule #1: When in doubt, always, always, go with hitting over pitching......especially when the hitter is clearly better than the pitcher(s).
Rule #2: Never keep a closer (unless you are in a super-deep league or you are keeping 10+ players)
All of this is a very long way of saying:
Keep Encarnacion and don't even think twice about it!
help with mine?http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=454769