Dynasty League need 15 keepers..WHIR

[FrostbiteFalls]

12 team keeper league..15 Keepers, 4 minor league players
We play: 2C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, MI,CI, 5 OF, U, 5 SP, 5 RP
stat cat: BA, RAB (runs per @ bat), TBI(teammates batted in), TB(total bases)
ERA, Kd9, S, W

I am keeping :

Mauer
C.Santana
S. Castro
A. Craig
D. Young
Gallardo
Gio
Grienke
Samardzija
Matt Moore


I am undecided about these players:

A. Gonzo
K. Seager
B. Lawrie
Pence
Pagan
BJ Upton
B, Moss
Victorino
I. Kennedy
Beachy

Who would you keep? Would you keep the players that I would?

Thanks for your help
WHIR

[plamb23]

12 team keeper league..15 Keepers, 4 minor league players
We play: 2C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, MI,CI, 5 OF, U, 5 SP, 5 RP
stat cat: BA, RAB (runs per @ bat), TBI(teammates batted in), TB(total bases)
ERA, Kd9, S, W

I am keeping :

Mauer
C.Santana
S. Castro
A. Craig
D. Young
Gallardo
Gio
Grienke
Samardzija
Matt Moore


I am undecided about these players:

A. Gonzo
K. Seager
B. Lawrie
Pence
Pagan
BJ Upton
B, Moss
Victorino
I. Kennedy
Beachy

Who would you keep? Would you keep the players that I would?

Thanks for your help
WHIR

Why would you consider keeping Delmon Young?

[jtsandwich]

[quote="FrostbiteFalls"]12 team keeper league..15 Keepers, 4 minor league players
We play: 2C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, MI,CI, 5 OF, U, 5 SP, 5 RP
stat cat: BA, RAB (runs per @ bat), TBI(teammates batted in), TB(total bases)
ERA, Kd9, S, W

I am keeping :

Mauer
C.Santana
S. Castro
A. Craig
D. Young
Gallardo
Gio
Grienke
Samardzija
Matt Moore


I am undecided about these players:

A. Gonzo
K. Seager
B. Lawrie
Pence
Pagan
BJ Upton
B, Moss
Victorino
I. Kennedy
Beachy

Who would you keep? Would you keep the players that I would?

Thanks for your help
WHIR[

I would NOT keep Delmon Yound, I like A Gone and Lawrie more than a couple you stated.

[HOOTIE]

Why would you be undecided on AGon?

AGon
BJ
Lawrie
Seager
Pence
Victorino

no D Young

[bigoz89]

As said before me, Delmon Young is not a keeper.

I would go

A Gon
Seager
Lawrie
Pence
BJ Upton
Beachy

A little help please? viewtopic.php?t=454422

[MadDog36]

C Mauer
C/1b/CI C. Santana
1b/of A. Gonzo
1b/of A. Craig
2b/3b/SS K. Seager (could carry multi position eligibility good power and plays thin position was beast on road last year and with smaller dimensions I think you will see a spike in his homer production - on top of that he has better lineup protection)
SS S. Castro
3b B. Lawrie
OF BJ Upton
15th keeper*
SP Gallardo Gio Grienke Samardzija Matt Moore B Beachy

Here is 14 keepers. The rest of your options are marginal. I think Pence is declining and a bit overrated. Who knows what to expect out of Victorino.

*I have an unusual idea. You seem to need power in your keepers and though the following player doesn't rank in the top tier of your keepers. Its an idea due to the fact that he A) broke out last year and B) pretty much starts all alone at this point. A full season of ABs could mean a 277/35/100 seaosn out of him. That easily outpaces pence. The guy I'm referring to is Brandon Moss. Really he could be another Mike Morse breaking out in his late twenties. he's shown the ability to hit for power in teh minors so I think last season IMO was not a fluke. He has lineup protection and will be a solid deep leageu CI or UTL bat for you. Seeing your other keepers you need all the power you can get. I think you can safely let both Vic and Pence (who are nothing spectacular in favor of this upside play). These kinds of gutsy calls are the make/break of a championship.

Kept Beachy over Kennedy - who had one great season and has been at best a mid rotation starter elsewise. I think you should select him as your 14th because yes you'll have to wait on him and this is a dynasty league and he has ace potential when he comes back and beyond this season.

Good luck.