Keeper Question: Zimmerman or Reyes? WHIR

[Fantasy Addict]

Would you keep Zimmerman (3B Nats) or Reyes (SS Jays) next year?

Our league scoring is as follows:

H2H
Hitting:
R, HR, RBI, SB, K, BB, TB, F% AVG.

[plamb23]

I think I would go Reyes

I think he'll flourish in that Jay lineup, also top SS is great to have in H2H IMO

[jtsandwich]

H2H I would lean towards Reyes as well. In a standard 5x5 roto I would go Zimerman because I believe you can fill SB's throughout the yr.

[sixersfan105]

Reyes for sure. I was actually just having the "Ryan Zimmerman is overrated" conversation at work today. Z has had ONE season in his seven year career with more than 25 HRs. ONE. at the hot corner. unacceptable.

please see my "Would I be crazy not to keep Dickey?" post. thanks.

[fsbarren]

Most of the H2H keeper rankings have Reyes a little ahead of Zimmerman, but I think the other question is who your other keepers are and how they complement each other. If it's just one keeper, I agree with the other posters with Reyes, though I have some concerns about both players.

Good luck.

[dannahann]

In a vacuum Reyes, but it really depends on who else is being kept.

[exm]

Reyes. Zimmerman IS overrated and 3B is pretty deep this year.

[MadDog36]

Reyes in a landslide.