Help me pick my last 2 keepers (Update)

[oakscorps]

12 team H2H league 5x5 C, 1B, 2B, ss, 3B, OF, OF, OF, and pitching positions SP, SP, Sp, P, P, RP, RP with 2 UTIL spots

I already know I'm keeping the following

A. Gonzalez (1B)
R. Cano (2B)
J. Reyes (SS)
Bautista (3B/OF)
J. Upton (OF)
Trumbo (3B/OF)
A. Hill (UTIL)
G. Gonzalez (SP)

So it comes down to the following 2 out of 5 to pick from. Im leaning towards Mccann only because I dont think there will be a better C out there but I'm torn between the other 4 as neither of them stand out. I might be able to trade Moore for Cespades the OF from Oakland

Mccann
Reddick
J. Johnson
Papelborn
Matt Moore

[Pogotheostrich]

I wouldn't keep McCann. Catcher is really deep this year and it sounds like he still isn't 100%.

I'd keep Moore and Papelbon.

[GiantsFan14]

Moore and Reddick. I'd take Cespedes for Moore too.

[HOOTIE]

I wouldn't keep McCann. Catcher is really deep this year and it sounds like he still isn't 100%.

I'd keep Moore and Papelbon.

I would be ok with Reddick instead of Papelbon.
Moore will be a better keeper SP then Gio.
Book it.

JJ and McCann aren't close imo.

[plamb23]

I would keep Moore and Reddick, and not trade Moore

[lane_anasazi2]

I would keep Moore and Reddick, and not trade Moore

That sounds right to me.