Another Pujols trade question

[plamb23]

12 team, 5x5 roto, keep 15 (won league last year)

I have these as keeps:
McCann
Pujols
Kinsler
Zimmerman
Freeman
Rutledge
Trout
Cutch
Willingham
Ellsbury

Minors (not counted against): Profar

Price
Wainwright
Scherzer

Soriano/JJohnson/Romo


Do I trade Pujols/Kinsler for Votto/Machado/Seager?

So basically, Pujols for Votto and Kinsler for Machado/Seager

Will try to HIR

[GiantsFan14]

Not even close to enough imo.

Pujols>Votto
Kinsler>>>>>>Machado+Seager

[plamb23]

I think in keeper I'd take Votto slightly ahead of Pujols----agree on Kinsler>machado/seager


What do you think about
Pujols/Wainwright for Votto/Machado/Seager?

[GiantsFan14]

I'd still pass.

[speedy27]

I too would pass on both.

[Element]

I prefer Votto and Pujols slightly, but rest of the trades are extremely lopsided.

[kaiser]

Given the choice between keeping Pujols or Votto, with no other considerations (such as auction values, etc.), I'm still going to go with Pujols, although I suspect this may be the last year that I would answer that way.

I don't think you should make any of the deals you are considering.

[dannahann]

I guess I just don't understand your motive here? I can see preferring Votto to Pujols they are close and that all comes down to personal preference. But why the big overpay to land Seager and Machado? You already have a far superior option at 3B to either player. If it's in the hope Manny gets SS eligibility back you have Rutledge there now and Profar coming? I kinda prefer Votto to Albert a little bit too but I wouldn't overpay by that much to get him.