Choose My Keeper..Draft My Pick

[moozzy77]

12T 2h2 (R, HR, RBI, XBH, SB, AVG, OPB)

Would you keep: J.Upton or A. Gonzalez?

You have the 6th pick in the draft. How would you rank these players...Assuming you are going to continue to keep Upton for the foreseeable future...

A.Jones
Beltre/Kinsler (Hasn't decided on his keeper)
Bautista
Wright
Holliday
Teixeira
Harper
Heyward
Bruce
Goldschmidt
Granderson
Hanley
Zimmerman
A. Ramirez
Posey

I can get another one of these players in the 2nd round..

[CyboNinja]

Keep AGon.

I would rank them as follows...

Posey
Hanley
Beltre
Kinsler
Wright
Bats
Bruce
Holiday
Grandy
Zimm
Heyward
Upton
AmRam
Tex
Harper
Goldy

[HOOTIE]

Upton by a lot

I have 7 guys in the top tier

Harper
Holliday
Bautista
Posey
Heyward
Upton
Bruce

[Kimbos Beard]

Keep: J.Upton

I didnt rank these guys in a particular order, because I think it may depend on who is already on your team. But this was my top tier 7

Beltre
Bautista
Wright
Holliday
Harper
Heyward
Posey

[Pogotheostrich]

Upton

If you can keep him Harper. If you can't I like Bautista.

[kaiser]

Upton by a lot

I have 7 guys in the top tier

Harper
Holliday
Bautista
Posey
Heyward
Upton
Bruce

I'm in agreement with Hootie's picks.

[lane_anasazi2]

Upton. And if this is a situation where you can keep these guys long term, I think Harper and Heyward are in a class by themselves.

[Element]

Upton. And if this is a situation where you can keep these guys long term, I think Harper and Heyward are in a class by themselves.

Yup. But I put Upton in that same group. It's not like he's old.

[moozzy77]

Thanks for the feedback. We are only allowed to keep one hitter each season but for as long as we want. My plan is to keep Justin Upton year in and out, so I'm really only drafting for next season. Unless you think I should draft harper or heyward to keep forever but I see Bautista as a good short term option (but i smell PEDs)

[jtsandwich]

Upton by a lot

I have 7 guys in the top tier

Harper
Holliday
Bautista
Posey
Heyward
Upton
Bruce

Agree top 7, not in that order, need more of your team info to rank these guys.