12 team 6x6 H2H with OPS and QS keeper league with no restrictions on keepers. I should mention that this league has 1 catcher. Also no CI or MI, just simply C,1B, 2B, 3B, SS,... etc.
Anyhow, out of this group of players, which 4 would you keep? I noted the players I'm leaning towards but I'd really like to know what the group thinks
Josh Willingham** Yoenis Cespedes** Hunter Pence** Cory Hart** Wilin Rosario Salvador Perez Mike Napoli Brandon Beachy Josh Johnson
I think you have it right. Any one of those three catchers are tempting but because you only play one, you should be able to get them back in the draft.
"In the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and has been widely regarded as a bad move."- Douglas Adams
MaudDib wrote:I think you have it right. Any one of those three catchers are tempting but because you only play one, you should be able to get them back in the draft.
I am with this, I take the four you listed, but I might be tempted to grab one of the catchers, especiall since 3 of the 4 players you would keep are only OF eligibile (assuming Hart has 1B eligibility in your league)
MaudDib wrote:I think you have it right. Any one of those three catchers are tempting but because you only play one, you should be able to get them back in the draft.
I am with this, I take the four you listed, but I might be tempted to grab one of the catchers, especiall since 3 of the 4 players you would keep are only OF eligibile (assuming Hart has 1B eligibility in your league)
I got Votto inked in at 1B so Hart/Pence will occupy one of my two utility positions. Also we don't have OF we have LF, CF, and RF. Pedroia and Hanley are my other 2 no-brain keepers.
My concern lies with Willingham. I'm not certain he can hit 30+ HRs again givin his age and his health. Last season I kept Hosmer over Trout and my butt is still sore from kicking myself in it all year long. I ended up just releasing Hosmer for an extra streamer in late August. I would hate to make that same mistake again and miss out on another stud who I already had...
MaudDib wrote:I think you have it right. Any one of those three catchers are tempting but because you only play one, you should be able to get them back in the draft.
I am with this, I take the four you listed, but I might be tempted to grab one of the catchers, especiall since 3 of the 4 players you would keep are only OF eligibile (assuming Hart has 1B eligibility in your league)
I got Votto inked in at 1B so Hart/Pence will occupy one of my two utility positions. Also we don't have OF we have LF, CF, and RF. Pedroia and Hanley are my other 2 no-brain keepers.
My concern lies with Willingham. I'm not certain he can hit 30+ HRs again givin his age and his health. Last season I kept Hosmer over Trout and my butt is still sore from kicking myself in it all year long. I ended up just releasing Hosmer for an extra streamer in late August. I would hate to make that same mistake again and miss out on another stud who I already had...
I am not certain that Willingham will be able to repeat those numbers from last year either but I think you keep him anyway. I like Sal Perez a lot but I can't justify keeping him over any of those guys and none of the catchers are going to make you regret it like Trout did of course no one saw what Trout did coming.
I like Beachy as well but he will be out half the year and he will be much easier to get back in the draft than any of these hitters.
"In the beginning the Universe was created. This has made a lot of people very angry and has been widely regarded as a bad move."- Douglas Adams
Cafe Home
Fantasy Football
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by CyboNinja » Mon Jan 14, 2013 10:09 am 
