Should I trade Felix?(WHIR)

[kidsilk]

16 team, 32 man rosters, auction league, 260 dollar cap, an keep as many players as you want per year. 5x5 cats roto style. Each player's contract goes up 3 dollars each year kept.

Been offered the following:

Yu Darvish(19), Mat Latos(19), Emilio Bonifacio(8), Alex Gordon(19) for My Felix(32), Ben Zobrist(20), AJ Burnett(2), and Nick Swisher(11). These are all values before the 3 dollars added for a keeper.

What do you think?

My Team:


MY ROSTER:

C-Martin(3)
C-Ruiz(2)
1B-Fielder(40)
2B-Zobrist(20)
SS-Pennington(2)
3B-Chipper(2)
MI-Kendrick(15)
CI-Hart(17)
OF-RIos(4)
OF-Swisher(11)
OF-Soriano(1)
OF-Murphy(1)
OF-Young(11)
BN-Byrd(1)
BN-K. Suzuki(3)
BN-Aybar(7)
BN-Raburn(1)
BN-Hafner(1)

P-Felix(32)
P-Burnett(2)
P-Casilla(1)
P-Buerhle(1)
P-Chen(1)
P-Correia(1)
P-Detwiler(1)
P-Hernandez(3)
P-Rauch(1)
P-H. Rodriguez(1)
P-Salas(3)

[SecretAgentMan]

16 team, 32 man rosters, auction league, 260 dollar cap, an keep as many players as you want per year. 5x5 cats roto style. Each player's contract goes up 3 dollars each year kept.

Been offered the following:

Yu Darvish(19), Mat Latos(19), Emilio Bonifacio(8), Alex Gordon(19) for My Felix(32), Ben Zobrist(20), AJ Burnett(2), and Nick Swisher(11). These are all values before the 3 dollars added for a keeper.

What do you think?

My Team:


MY ROSTER:

C-Martin(3)
C-Ruiz(2)
1B-Fielder(40)
2B-Zobrist(20)
SS-Pennington(2)
3B-Chipper(2)
MI-Kendrick(15)
CI-Hart(17)
OF-RIos(4)
OF-Swisher(11)
OF-Soriano(1)
OF-Murphy(1)
OF-Young(11)
BN-Byrd(1)
BN-K. Suzuki(3)
BN-Aybar(7)
BN-Raburn(1)
BN-Hafner(1)

P-Felix(32)
P-Burnett(2)
P-Casilla(1)
P-Buerhle(1)
P-Chen(1)
P-Correia(1)
P-Detwiler(1)
P-Hernandez(3)
P-Rauch(1)
P-H. Rodriguez(1)
P-Salas(3)

No way. Darvish is overrated as is Gordon and neither is at a bargain price. Swisher is fairly cheap and Zobrist is at a bit of a discount and carries some fair value being multi-position elig. Add in Felix H. being swapped for Latos (who I like but Latos is no Felix H) and that is just a bad deal for you imo.

[wildcatbandit525]

I like this deal. This would give you two quality pitchers.

[MaudDib]

I have said in the past, I like the deal. I think it is going to boil down to what people think Darvish is going to be. I like Darvish and think he has the upside of being a top 15 SP. So I see this deal as a top 5 SP for two top 15 SP. I also think Gordon is under-rated and will be a solid OF. I don't think either side is getting the better deal, I just think it is a fair trade from both sides.

[kidsilk]

This trade just got changed by the guy offering it because he traded Latos in another deal. He is now offering the following:

Melky(10), Bonifacio(8), Yu(19), Hechavarria(1), Gordon(19), Straily(1), Harrison(1) for Felix(32), Ruiz(2), Swisher(11), Burnett(2), and Murphy(1).

What do you think about this now?

[MaudDib]

This trade just got changed by the guy offering it because he traded Latos in another deal. He is now offering the following:

Melky(10), Bonifacio(8), Yu(19), Hechavarria(1), Gordon(19), Straily(1), Harrison(1) for Felix(32), Ruiz(2), Swisher(11), Burnett(2), and Murphy(1).

What do you think about this now?

Now it is an easy no. The one thingi liked in the last deal was the two starters. The new deal is one good starter and a lot of replaceable players.

[kidsilk]

Now he says he will add Ian Kennedy(17) to the trade. He really wants Felix! Lol does adding Kennedy make this trade a go?

[MaudDib]

Now he says he will add Ian Kennedy(17) to the trade. He really wants Felix! Lol does adding Kennedy make this trade a go?

Not for me. I personally want quality not quantity and you aren't getting enough quality.