Jay,C.Johnson for McDonald, Burnett, Scutaro, and Ruiz?WHIR

[kidsilk]

NL ONLY, auction type with 260 dollar cap, 5x5 roto style, can keep 9 players.

I have been offered the following:

His James McDonald(3), AJ Burnett(1), Marco Scutaro(8), and Carlos Ruiz(15) for my John Jay(1) and Chris Johnson(5). What do you think and who of the following should I keep?

My Team:
C-Barajas(7)
C-Kotarras(2)
1B-Izturis(1)
2B-Descalso(3)
3B-Headley(12)
SS-Pastornicky(5)
MI-Theriot(4)
CI-C.Johnson(5)
OF-CarGo(42)
OF-Jay(1)
OF-Maybin(11)
OF-Pierre(2)
OF-Stanton(28)
U-Arias(1)
P-S.Burnett(1)
P-S.Casilla(1)
P-Fancisco(18)
P-Garza(20)
P-Harang(4)
P-E.Jackson(7)
P-Stults(1)
P-C. Young(1)
P-J. Turner(1)

[kidsilk]

Woops, forgot to type in Jay Bruce at 34 bucks. I have him too. Thanks and leave your links.

[c1turbo]

I would do it. Your getting IMO, good value pitching along with improving MI and C positions.
And your team needs more pitching and help in the MI and C.
Chris Johnson is probably the better bat compared to Jon Jay because of opportunity.
I don't believe CJ will keep up his numbers last year after being traded.

It was just like when he was first called up. He got hot and then next year slumped and K'ed all the time.

[kidsilk]

Anyone else? And who would you keep?

[Element]

I think that you need to do it. The roster looks weak even for an NL only. I struggled to find 9 players pre-trade. I could see holding all 4 players that you're receiving. I am not high on Johnson at all. It hurts to move Jay, but whatever.

[MaudDib]

Agree with the others, I would do the deal.

Bruce
Headley
CarGo
Stanton
EJackson
Garza
Maybin
Burnett
McDonald

That seems like the 9 I would keep but a number of them aren't locks and could depend on league settings.