I'm in a 16-team dynasty league where you keep all your players year to year, it's H2H 6x6 categories (standard 5x5 plus OBP and holds), we start 2 1B and 2 3B.
I give: Jameson Taillon and Neftali Feliz
I get: Allen Craig
My team is:
bench-gordon beckham, ichiro, alcides, juan francisco, tyler moore, gary sanchez, josh bell, francisco lindor
pitchers- Bauer, harvey, Pineda, B. Anderson, Felix, Darvish, Arroyo, Neftali, Matusz, Pomeranz, Rafael Soriano, Cishek, Andrew Bailey, bundy
My thinking is that I don't really trust Dunn or Davis, but at least one of the two should be useful for the next few years. My offense could be finished for a long time if I get Craig. But at the same time, that's a ton of talent to give up and it could come back to bite me in the ass.
BQ: Would you still do the trade if it were Pineda and Taillon for Craig?