2013 Keeper League keepers..NEED HELP

[Gliker05]

I'm sorry if this isn't the proper place to post this, but I don't post on forums often and this seemed like a good place to post this. For the 2012 fantasy baseball season, I joined a first year keeper league. The rules are simple, for the 2013 season we may keep 3 players from our 2012 rosters, can't be our first picks, and wherever we drafted that player, is the position we give up in the 2013 draft. Another factor is since I won the league, I will be drafting last in 2013. Having said that, which three keepers would you hold on to, and if you could give a brief reason why, that would be helpful. Thank you for your time. Also, it is a 12-team league.

Round 3: Andrew McCutchen (keep in mind, 12 team league, last pick, snake draft, means this would act as the 36th pick of the draft)
Round 7: Madison Bumgarner
Round 8: Buster Posey
Round 13: Johnny Cueto
Round 15: Ryan Howard
Round 16: Edwin Encarnacion
Round 19: Yoenis Cespedes
Round 25: Aroldis Chapman and Fernando Rodney (we can only keep on person we picked up off the waiver wire, so i could only keep 1 of them, but either will act as my last pick)

Thanks for reading.

[Frenchiegangsta9]

this isnt the proper forum but I'll help you out anyway. Since I'm a nice guy.

Posey, Encarnacion and Chapman. Chapman moving to the rotation takes a hit in value so It would be reasonable to switch him out for Cespedes.

[fast dogs]

Draft, Trade, Keeper and Waivers Questions would have been where to post...
Cutch Posey & EE for me.
I wouldn't take either pitcher ahead of these hitters. Chap as a starter has some Q's to be answered & I wouldn't take a closer as a keeper in a 3 keeper league

[Element]

Cutch, E5 & Cespedes ... unless it's a 2 catcher league. Then I hold Posey over E5.

[baseball77]

McCutchen, Posey, and Cespedes

[wildcatbandit525]

McCutcheon, Encarnacion and Cespedes

[MaudDib]

McCutchen and EE are the easy ones. I think I would take Posey. I am still not a believer in Cespedes and getting Posey in the 8th is better value IMO.

[FBB Junky]

McCutchen isnt that great of a value @36 vs some other guys on this list..IMO

Posey
E.E
Cespedes

BOOM

[High NTight]

I'll join the crowd...........McCutchen, Posey and EE

[FBB Junky]

Did any of you look as Cespedas vs McCutchen last year? You would be silly to take him in 3rd vs Cespedas a whole bunch later!!