Addison Reed or Tom Wilhelmsen?

[Little Johnny]

I can trade away a $31 Adam Jones for a $4 Addison Reed or a $1 Tom Wilhelmsen. I'm going to make the deal, but I'm not sure which closer to deal for. Do you prefer Reed or Wilhelmsen?

Thanks for any input.

Johnny

[americanleagueroto]

I can trade away a $31 Adam Jones for a $4 Addison Reed or a $1 Tom Wilhelmsen. I'm going to make the deal, but I'm not sure which closer to deal for. Do you prefer Reed or Wilhelmsen?

Thanks for any input.

Johnny

I prefer Wilhelmsen even before you factor in the $3 savings. That said, it is close between the 2 in a vacuum, but the savings should put the Bartender over the top for sure.

Dave

[cannonarm21]

+1 for Wilhelmsen

[MaudDib]

I would probably go with Wilhelmsen here but I would not be surprised if Reed ended up being the most valuable of the two. I think Reed has the stuff to be a top 5 closer at some point.