It does look like you have a different setting this year than last, and I don't see a transaction changing it, so either it did not import properly, or it got changed during the registration process. I haven't seen any other reports of this problem, but it is possible. I'll try to look into it.
Just wanted to follow up on this.. I tested by creating a new league and importing settings and confirmed this setting did not import properly. It imported as Wait to be called up instead of As Yahoo adds them. I've reached out to customer care to change, but does look like a bug of some sort.