Crazy offer for Sterlin Castro...WHIR

[prguy1979]

I was just offered Doug Fister 2.1, Manny Machado 2.1, Jacoby Ellsbury 10.1 and Aaron Hill 5.3 for my Sterlin Castro 6.1 my league settings are below along wiht my keepers

In a 14 team auctions and rotisserie keeper league....100 budget....that requieres you to have:
2 catchers, 1 of each 1st, 2nd, 3rd, SS, CI, and MI, 4 OF, 2 UT(any position), 5 SP, 3 RP, 2 Swingmen (any pitcher)

categories are:

BA, BB, R, RBI, SB, SLG, ERA, HD(Holds), K, S, W, WHIP
My Keeper are...
M. Trout(2.10), S. Castro(6.1), P. Fielder(16.2), A. Jones(8.0), S. Marte(2.1) J. Bruce(12.8),D. Wright(11.6), D. Price(8.1), C. Sale(5.0), A. Wainwright(4.1), C. Perez(2.6)

[Element]

It was looking good until I saw Ellsbury. I wouldn't want that contract. He has had 1 healthy season; in which he over-performed to boot. I would stick with StArlin myself.

[prguy1979]

It was looking good until I saw Ellsbury. I wouldn't want that contract. He has had 1 healthy season; in which he over-performed to boot. I would stick with StArlin myself.

Ellsbury is just a toss in with the team that I already have I wouldnt need him. Our league has a ton of Red Sox fans whom I could trade him later in the off season for. The real question is if Machado, Hill, Fister is enough for Sterlin.

[NYMetsGM]

I would keep Starlin not Sterlin

[MaudDib]

Keep Starlin.

Ellsbury isn't a great contract even if you can deal him off. Hill is a little pricey for a guy who was barely ownable a season ago. Machado is a nice price but I don't see much production from him this year, probably another year or two away from being able to start him.

[MadDog36]

Starlin - important for your team.