What do you guys think....

[ntremain23]

I think i've made my choice,but which of these pitchers would you rather have on your team.It's a 8-team keeper.

Roger Clemens
Al Leiter
Jamie Moyer
Kevin Brown
Russ Ortiz
Ramon Ortiz
Brian Lawrence
Andy Pettitte
C.C. Sabathia

[wrveres]

There is only one pitcher on that list that can give you 15 wins's every year for the next five years, Pettitte. Time to toss the old guys to the curb, The Ortiz's run a close second. Lawrence and Sabathia toss for 2 deplorable teams that show no sign's of improving.

Wins are the hardest thing to predict in Fanatsy Ball, they require a "team effort". Pettite pitches in the most lopsided division and is secure in his job with the best team 160.00 mil can buy. I say you could write in 15 wins easily for him every year for 5 more years.

Pettitte

[THE MASHER]

In a keeper league, the only pitcher that makes sense to me is Sabathia or Lawrence. ALL of the other guys are even bigger question marks. Honestly, I wouldn't keep ANY of them. Clemens, Moyer and Leiter are all old (but very nice options for 1 year) - Pettite and Brown are perpetual injury risks and can't be counted on for too much (if they can maintain health though, all bets are off) and the Ortizes could just as easily get lit up this year. This doesn't leave you with too many options, but from this list you have limited options. Good luck, though!!

[superotto80]

AL LEITER!! he is gonna have a great year this yr i an feel it. at least 15 wins and 200k's

[superotto80]

seriously though leiter is gonna have a good yr but for a keeper league i would also go with pettite

[Guest]

Keeper league I would say Sabathia.

[shizzlemynizzle]

Sabathia in a keeper league.

[metsfan1969]

Sabathia would probably be the best choice for a keeper. He's young, talented, and has most all of his potentially stellar career ahead of him.

For one year of gratification I would say Leiter (because I'm biased ) has a great chance or a healthy Brown should be one of the top 5 or so this year.