Element wrote:With no trades I would keep McCutchen, Holliday and Wright; releasing Felix & Kinsler. If you make the trade you would need to cut one of the three that we're keeping. That upgrade, to me, isn't nearly enough to compensate for the downgrade from Sale to any one of the other three.
I dont think you are following my keeper league rules correctly. I have 5 guys who either need to be kept, traded or sent back to the draft. I can only keep three of those. I am thinking about trading King Felix and Sale in a deal to get Hamilton and someone else. I would then have as red players Ham, Cutch, Kinsler/Wright.
I was simply asking peoples thoughts on the trade. I know that most people favor bats over arms and considering I cant keep Felix anyways I was trying to land a big bat.
My keepers as of now are:
Cutch, Wright, Sale, Desmond, A. Jones, Heyward, Kinsler, A. Jackson. We keep 8. I might also be landing Hanley.