Which 6 to keep for 2013?

[SecretAgentMan]

5x5 Roto, 10 team keeper. Can keep any 6.

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig, Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw, Weaver, Cain, Sale, Cueto, Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

[kaiser]

Tough one. I usually lean toward all offense for keepers, but you have such a massive rotation, I have to say keep some of it.

5x5 Roto, 10 team keeper. Can keep any 6.

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig, Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw , Weaver , Cain, Sale, Cueto , Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

[MaudDib]

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig, Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw , Weaver , Cain , Sale, Cueto, Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

Kipnis is the last one in but I like him more than Zimmerman. Wouldn't really have a problem with either one though and Craig would be #3.

[Element]

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig, Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw , Weaver , Cain , Sale, Cueto, Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

Kipnis is the last one in but I like him more than Zimmerman. Wouldn't really have a problem with either one though and Craig would be #3.

I agree. Plus, already having Wright makes this an easier decision.

[Dbgrenier]

Pedroia
Wright
Zobrist
Kershaw
Cain
Cuento/Weaver, your preferance.

Good luck!

[SecretAgentMan]

I am a little surprised at the Kipnis following. He had a nice season, but over Zimmerman or Craig or Morse and I already would be keeping a 2b in Pedroia?

[ensanimal]

I would keep a max of 2 SP's only. Do you an IF spot for Zimm?


2b: Pedroia
3b: Wright
SP: Kershaw, Weaver

These four for sure. The "safe" route would be Zimm and Zobrist I think. Morse and Craig could be the homerun picks though. I don't think I'd keep Zimm without a starting spot though.

[SecretAgentMan]

I would keep a max of 2 SP's only. Do you an IF spot for Zimm?


2b: Pedroia
3b: Wright
SP: Kershaw, Weaver

These four for sure. The "safe" route would be Zimm and Zobrist I think. Morse and Craig could be the homerun picks though. I don't think I'd keep Zimm without a starting spot though.

We start an IF and Util, so there is a starting spot for him. I tend to agree with keeping 2 SPs, but I think Cain offers too much value to let walk. Needless to say I am going to try to do a 2 for 1 to upgrade a bat but the league is extremely trade hostile so I can't rely on that.

[fast dogs]

5x5 Roto, 10 team keeper. Can keep any 6.

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig , Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw Weaver Cain Sale, Cueto, Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

this gives you the option of best 1st base or OF with the 1st pick w/ Craig

[Pvigs]

5x5 Roto, 10 team keeper. Can keep any 6.

C: AJ Pierzynski, Wieters
1b: Rizzo
2b: Pedroia
SS: Jeter
3b: Wright
IF: Zimmerman
OF: Craig, Morse, A. Soriano, Zobrist, Ross
Util: Kipnis
Bench: Reddick

SP: Kershaw, Weaver, Cain, Sale, Cueto, Kendrick, Niese, Carpenter
CL: Kenley Jansen
Bench: Marcum

Please help viewtopic.php?t=452354