Braun+Hill for Posey+H. Ramirez+Fielder WHIR

[punswaterboy]

League type: H2H points non keeper
The other owner is also in the championship game.

The trade is Ryan Braun and Aaron Hill for Buster Posey, Hanley Ramirez, and Prince Fielder.
In catcher, I have Josh Donaldson
In first, I have Adam LaRoche(1b), Joey Votto(3b/1b), and Garrett Jones(BE)
In SS, I have Jeter(SS)

Points wise, this is a beter trade for me, but I would have to decent SS and 2 decent 1B. Help?

For help, post link in comments.

[Element]

So you're trading with the guy that you're facing in your league's championship game?

If you give him Braun & Hill, how much do you upgrade those positions for him?

[MaudDib]

If you are in the title game against this guy, i think i stay put. Stick with what got you to the championship. There is no clear winner here and over the next week it is a coin flip on who will actually produce more so stick with what you have and hope it keeps doing what it did all year.