Keep 8 $

[RedTiger]

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

[Element]

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

[RedTiger]

Thank you. I can only keep 8, sorry if my post was a little confusing. Without going too much deeper into the keeper rules, 3 of the players will have to be Rizzo, Goldschmidt, Rutledge, Altuve, etc because their salaries have been doubled.

I personally have been leaning towards

1B Rizzo 2
1B Goldschmidt 4
SS Rutledge 2

C Molina 6
OF Heyward 10
OF Bruce 18
3B Lawrie 8
P Cain 22

But Medlen is definitely making this tough.

[Element]

Updated my list. I removed Howard and Frazier. You already have some good 1B options and Frazier shouldn't cost too much next season unless he has a Freese-like post season. I wouldn't keep Cain at that cost. Often time it's not worth paying a premium on pitching. Cain has had a career season & it wouldn't shock me to see him come back down to his career norms. I'd rather take the $6 gamble on Medlen. I'd definitely pay the $6 to find out if he is for real or not.

[medium_robin]

Your list of 8 seems about right. I wouldn't worry too much about Medlen. I don't think he'll produce like he is right now for a full season. He's due for some regression. Of your keepers, I like Bruce the least (never been a big fan, too many K's, low avg makes me nervous). He's a good player, but also one of your most expensive.

[MaudDib]

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

I like Cain and Wainwright too much to pass on them. They might be a little higher priced then I normally like to go but I think they are top 10 SP and still priced cheaper than I think they will go next year at auction. Not sold on keeping Rizzo so i would have no problem taking Rutledge instead.

[drtodddds]

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

thanks for helping me with mine

[Padres Fan]

Thanks for the help with mine

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

[Cream]

Thanks for the help on mine - sorry for the delay in response.

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Anthony Rizzo $2
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
2B Jose Altuve $4
SS Josh Rutledge $2
3B Brett Lawrie $8
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
OF Shane Victorino $11
1B Ryan Howard $10
OF Starling Marte $4
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6

Last spot comes down to Molina, Cain, Bruce... I think that comes down to a personal preference on if you'd want to keep a C and if you feel comfortable only keeping 1 SP. I'd lean towards Cain personally.

[americanleagueroto]

10 Team, 6x6 roto (add holds and ops): devalues all relievers and adds value to power
$270 budgets
14 hitters, 9 pitchers
C,C,1B,2B,SS,3B,CI,MI, 5 OF, U, 9 P

dollar values are what they will be next year

C Yadier Molina $6
1B Paul Goldschmidt $3/$4
3B/OF Todd Frazier $5
OF Jason Heyward $10
OF Jay Bruce $18
P Matt Cain $22
P Adam Wainwright $18
P Kris Medlen $6