Keeper help? WHIR

[hoopsgalnyc]

this is my team in a 10 team, 5x5 keeper w/obp instead of avg.

we keep 10 guys. who would you keep? i think the following are slam dunks:

1. cabrera
2. hamilton
3. beltre
4. phillips
5. cain
6. sabathia
7. gonzalez
8. teixeira

i'm open on the other 3.

your thoughts?


Matt Wieters
(Bal - C) Player notes
TB 7:05 pm 82% -/- - - - - -
1B
Ryan Howard
(Phi - 1B) Player notes
Mia 4:05 pm 60% -/- - - - - -
2B
Trevor Plouffe
(Min - 2B,3B,SS,RF) No new player Notes
KC 8:10 pm 21% -/- - - - - -
3B
Adrian Beltre
(Tex - 3B) Player notes
Cle 8:05 pm 93% -/- - - - - -
SS
Jimmy Rollins
(Phi - SS) Player notes
Mia 4:05 pm 84% -/- - - - - -
CI
Miguel Cabrera
(Det - 1B,3B) Player notes
@CWS 8:10 pm 98% -/- - - - - -
MI
Brandon Phillips
(Cin - 2B) No new player Notes
Pit 7:10 pm 91% -/- - - - - -
LF
Josh Hamilton
(Tex - LF,CF) Player notes
Cle 8:05 pm 91% -/- - - - - -
CF
Carlos Gomez
(Mil - CF) New player notes
Atl 8:10 pm 44% -/- - - - - -
RF
Jason Kubel
(Ari - LF,RF) Player notes
LAD 9:40 pm 41% -/- - - - - -
OF
Angel Pagan
(SF - CF) Player notes
@Col 8:40 pm 54% -/- - - - - -
OF
Ben Revere
(Min - LF,CF,RF) Player notes
KC 8:10 pm 28% -/- - - - - -
Util
Coco Crisp
(Oak - LF,CF) Player notes
@LAA 10:05 pm 32% -/- - - - - -
BN
Cody Ross
(Bos - LF,CF,RF) Player notes
NYY 7:10 pm 28% -/- - - - - -
BN
Carlos Beltran
(StL - CF,RF) Player notes
@SD 6:35 pm 76% -/- - - - - -
BN
Mark Teixeira
(NYY - 1B) Player notes
@Bos 7:10 pm 54% -/- - - - - -

SP
Matt Cain
(SF - SP) Player notes
@Col 8:40 pm 77% - - - - - -
SP
Kris Medlen
(Atl - SP,RP) Player notes
@Mil 8:10 pm 53% - - - - - -
SP
CC Sabathia
(NYY - SP) Player notes
@Bos 7:10 pm 66% - - - - - -
SP
Tyler Cloyd
(Phi - SP,RP) No new player Notes
Mia 4:05 pm 5% - - - - - -
RP
Jason Motte
(StL - RP) Player notes
@SD 6:35 pm 89% - - - - - -
RP
Tom Wilhelmsen
(Sea - RP) No new player Notes
@Tor 7:07 pm 67% - - - - - -
RP
Ernesto Frieri
(LAA - RP) Player notes
Oak 10:05 pm 73% - - - - - -
RP
Wilton Lopez
(Hou - RP) No new player Notes
ChC 8:05 pm 11% - - - - - -
P
Glen Perkins
(Min - RP) Player notes
KC 8:10 pm 30% - - - - - -
P
Sergio Romo
(SF - RP) Player notes
@Col 8:40 pm 49% - - - - - -
P
Javier Lopez
(SF - RP) No new player Notes
@Col 8:40 pm 18% - - - - - -
BN
Gio Gonzalez
(Was - SP) Player notes
@NYM 7:10 pm 78% - - - - - -
BN
Jake Peavy
(CWS - SP) Player notes
Det 8:10 pm 60% - - - - - -
BN
Wandy Rodriguez
(Pit - SP) Player notes
@Cin 7:10 pm 45% - - - - - -

[onitapgr]

Adrian Beltre
Miguel Cabrera
Brandon Phillips
Josh Hamilton
Carlos Beltran
Mark Teixeira
Matt Cain
CC Sabathia
Gio Gonzalez
Jake Peavy

[Element]

Adrian Beltre
Miguel Cabrera
Brandon Phillips
Josh Hamilton
Carlos Beltran
Mark Teixeira
Matt Cain
CC Sabathia
Gio Gonzalez
Jake Peavy

I'm keeping Medlan over Peavy. Otherwise, I agree.

[MadDog36]

For your two open slots Beltran and Medlen.

[prguy1979]

Medlan and Beltra, Wieters would be my #3 choice in case Tex injury is worse than expected. You might even want to consider keeping Wieters over Tex since Tex is a know slow starter.

[kaiser]

Adrian Beltre
Miguel Cabrera
Brandon Phillips
Josh Hamilton
Carlos Beltran
Mark Teixeira
Matt Cain
CC Sabathia
Gio Gonzalez
Jake Peavy

I'm keeping Medlan over Peavy. Otherwise, I agree.

Also think Medlin is the better choice over Peavy. Would also keep Weiters.