Drop Melky for Scutaro in keeper? WHIR please

[lane_anasazi2]

Once the average starts to go for the over 30 players it usually doesn't come back; similar thing with injuries except they tend to keep coming back.He might not be a bad keeper choice in your setup, but the days of him being a top 12 choice are gone and never to return.I wouldn't take him in the top 20 picks next year tho some surely will, I show him with 1 game @ 3rd base this year

Agreed. Losing 3B eligibility is a big deal, and as an OF I really don't like him as a 1st round pick.

[bayside]

Ya Bautista will NOT have 3B elgibilty in any non-tard leagues next year

[paperstacks1980]

I wouldn't do that

[PrideofthePhils1993]

Drop Melky for whoever you can immediately. The guy is as fake as they come and theres no way he hits nearly as well as he did this year ever again. Think about it, even when on the juice he only managed 11 home runs. His true value was in his average and run production and if he stops hitting .350 than those run totals will decrease and then we're looking at a very average player.

[jruffus1]

I ended up dropping him long ago lol. It became absolutely critical with the injuries to Grandy, Dunn, and Willingham.