Is this trade fair?

[kaiser]

EITHER you squash trading with too many 'rules' that are tough or impossible to define completely OR you build a vibrant long lasting keeper league which permits owners to improve THEIR teams THEIR way.

The best keeper leagues find a happy medium somewhere in between. You have to have some rules in place, and they have to be enforceable.

[mikeyaco35]

fair within the context of a season means that the trade is considered fair whether, or not it is a keeper league. That was you can avoid someone dumping six of their non keeper players for one keeper

[baegames]

What would be the point of a keeper league if fair means they have to be fair within context of a current season?

If you are out of contention, dump away. And get your best keepers for next year. If Team B thinks he is getting the best player in each deal (I think he is), that is what they should be doing.

The only question is why was the July 31 deadline not enforced?

Help with mine:

viewtopic.php?t=452025