Note: A hit counts hits x5. H, 1b/2b/3b, TB, AVG, OPS. A stolen base is only counted once. Hence, AVG/OPS are main stats to build off.
Roster C A.J. Ellis(LAD - C) 1B Adrián González(Bos - 1B,OF) 2B José Altuve(Hou - 2B) 3B Evan Longoria(TB - 3B) SS Marco Scutaro(SF - 2B,3B,SS) OF Melky Cabrera(SF - OF) OF Matt Holliday(StL - OF) OF Jason Kubel(Ari - OF) Util Elvis Andrus(Tex - SS)
I think Walker. He's showing a similar average and run total to Altuve with more power and more RBIs, hence higher OPS. The only drop would be in steals but I don't know how important that is with Melky, Andrus, and Victorino. Plus you have to like the Pirates going forward over the Astros.