RATE this trade please

[Rad Randall]

Our league is a 4 X 4 keeper league.....

Trade is a 5 for 5 between 2 teams and is as follows:

Steve Clevenger, Jay Bruce, J.D. Martinez, Pablo Sandoval & Micheal Fiers

in exchange for

A.J. Ellis, Norichika Aoki, John Jay, Placido Polanco & Trevor Clippard

.....without considering who wins the deal with regards to keepers etc......who wins this trade strictly on 2012 performance moving forward or is it a close trade with power & starter going 1 way & speed, avg & saves going the other?

Please advise. thanks

[KingOfSports]

I'd much rather have the top list of guys. Pablo and Bruce are the two best players in the deal. I don't even think its that close.

[dannahann]

The trade is strongly in favor of the top group.