lyons595 wrote:I'd do the deal, but we're talking about Vogelsong...Not Verlander. For some reason, I just can't see him being this good for long. But I am STRONGLY of the opinion that SP can be overrated and can be replaced easily (I love to stream/play matchups). I wouldn't include any draft picks and see what he says. If no, then go with as low a pick as possible. Its hard for me to advise you on what round as my league doesn't trade picks so I don't have a good feel for what a 9th, 12th, or 20th rounder is worth.
This... start with one-for-one and if he doesn't go for a straight-up deal, move on to adding the lowest possible pick (12th?) you'd be willing to give up. Not sure I'd go much lower than that, but then I like Viciedo for his power potential more than most folks do.
Thanks for the help with mine.