Closer question

[LeftyQB]

Anyone have an opinion on either Mesa or Chacon? Who should do better this year? i'm thinking about dropping Cliff Lee for one of them. Below is roster and scoring.
C - Leiberthal
1B - Teixeira
2B - Jimenez
3B - Hinske
SS - A-Rod
OF - Ordonez, Abreu, C. Lee
Util - Ibanez, Burnitz
Bench - Cintron, Matos
SP - Mulder, Millwood, L Hernandez
RP - Foulke, F. Cordero
P - Peavy, Radke
Bench - J. Thomson, C. Lee, Meche

SCORING:
1b - 1 pt,2b - 2 pts,3b - 3 pts, HR - 4 pts
RBI - 1 pt, R - 1 pt, BB - 1 pt, SB - 2 pts
Win - 8 pts, Save - 7 pts, K - 1 pt, CG - 5 pts, Hold - 4 pts, IP - 2 pts, ER - -1, Hit - -.5
BB - -.5

[DieHardCubbie]

That is a tuff choice....Shacon is a good pitcher...and has handled Colorado pretty well....but it is still Colorado....Mesa, when he is on he is good...but when he is off he is REAL bad...and there is no way to predict how he will be....

Of those two...I would go with Chacon....but with your scoring system....I might look to find a holds guy that wont hurt your ratios...before I picked up one of those...

[mattusd]

The choice is obviously Chacon...

but don't cut Cliff Lee... you should be cutting John Thomson. Cliff Lee offers way, way, way more upside.

it's a no-brainer.