First off, I love your use of the word choad. Wish more people brought it out.
Secondly, I don't think you should drop any of these pitchers. You should give us the rest of your lineup and the free agent hitters and pitchers that you're seeking. But if you MUST drop one of these guys, I'd say Sheets.
Mauer, A-Gonz, Pedroia, Miggy, E. Cabrera, Beltran, Morse, Holliday, Beltre, Gomez, Rizzo, puig, Hanley
Greinke, Johnson, Haren, wheeler, pineda, E santana, Ryu, Miller, Garza, Street, Frieri, Gregg, Putz, gregerson
10 man H2H Yahoo 5x5