too much for Kershaw?

[CubsFan4Life23]

He Declined my counter, so I am prepared to offer this...worth it

I give: Felix/Kipnis/Pence/Andrus/Papelbon
I get: Kershaw/Cano/Jennings/Chapman

good enough?

[CubsFan4Life23]

SO that did not work...

I offered him this new offer...

I give: Kipnis/Papelbon/Felix

I get: Jennings/Pablo/Chapman/Kershaw

or I have thought about offering him (Kipnis,Felix, Papelbon for either Jennings or Pablo along with Chapman and Kershaw)

Do they work for me?