Any reason to not do this trade?

[dubstar]

Was offered Kershaw for my Andrus/Hanson. I could keep Andus in round 13, and move up 1 round each year going forward. Keshaw can be kept at round 1 every year going forward. I think this helps me enough this year to try to win, I don't know what to expect out of Halladay and Sale will probably be limited. I would just slide Plouffe into SS.

10 team h2h keeper(keep 6)
R, HR, RBI, SB, OBP, XBH
W, SV, K, ERA, WHIP, QS

C Santana
1B Butler
2B Kinsler
3B Lawrie
SS Andrus
OF Bruce, Choo, Kemp
UTIL Willingham
BN Plouffe, Rizzo


SP Halladay, Gallardo, Hanson, Hellickson, Sale, Bauer, Vogelsong
RP Frieri, Johnson, Wilhelmsen

[MaudDib]

I would be ok with that deal. Kershaw isn't a great price if you lose a 1st round pick. You also have Kemp and Kinsler, are their draft values 1st round picks as well? If so then it makes Kershaw a lot better knowing he is more like a 3rd round pick. If those two aren't then I would probably be a lot more hesitant to do the deal.

[dubstar]

yes, I would keep Kershaw, Kemp and Kinsler 1-3. I'd keep Kershaw over Halladay going forward, this year I had Agon, Kemop and Halladay 1-3. Pretty much the same thing with different players.

[jcave24]

I personally would hold onto Andrus here. 13th round is a fantastic value for him, and it'll probably be a good 8 years before his draft value matches where he is really drafted in a redraft league.

viewtopic.php?t=450692