Butler & J. Hamilton for Pujols & A. Jones..WHIR

[Fran1508]

My billy butler and josh hamilton for his pujols and adam jones. Do I do the trade? Standard 5x5 league but its really 6x5 because ops is involved too. What do you think. WHIR, please

[Eastman19]

What is the rest of your team?

[Fran1508]

its a non-keeper league. 12 teams.
C - mccann
1b - butler
2b - kinsler
3b - wright
ss - peralta (tulo on DL)
3OF - bautista, hamilton, austin jackson
Util - Lind
Bn - Ruben tejada, kendry morales, brandon belt

[Eastman19]

I think I may do this...you have Bautista...Adam Jones gives you numbers across the board. I would take a shot at it.

[sigriffey]

Yes, I do it because Pujols is due for a monster half IMO and Jones is the complete package.

[Fran1508]

bump

[MurrayKy]

Thanks for the help on mine bud!

Yeah, I'd do it. I like Pujols better than Butler even in his slump, and Jones is a younger, more complete player than Hamilton. Maybe less average and HR/RBI, but even those are solid for him and he's great at everything else.

[lyons595]

Take it!
If you look at the trade position-by-position, you get a big upgrade at 1B and only drop off a little with Jones in the OF.

Thanks.

[germani40]

I would do it. Hamilton has really fallen off since his tremendous first start. I still think hes a great guy to have but I like what youre getting in return.


viewtopic.php?t=450594

[kidsilk]

I would take it. Jones has proven he is a bonafide All Star and Pujols is wel....Pujols. Hamilton is slowing down and Butler is nothing special. Take it.

thanks for your help with mine