Pedroia for Halladay? Help Please?

[tdasher06]

I really need pitching help in my league. I have been offered Halladay for Pedroia and one of the following oufielders. 1. Kendrys Morales, 2. Lance Berkman. 3. Michael Brantley. Halladay really hasnt proven much so far this season but his track record is what i'm looking at. Would I be giving up too much if I accepted this trade? I have Zobrist and Altuve to replace Pedroia.

[WaCougMBS]

Is it a keeper league? How are you doing in hitting? It looks like Zobrist and Altuve could be serviceable for you there, so I think Halladay and the best available hitter is probably worth a shot in a redraft where you need pitching. Not the first guy I'd go after, and I might demand better bat with Halladay, but if it's all you can do then address your biggest offensive need and take a shot in the dark IMO

[MaudDib]

I don't really love it but if you really need SP then maybe I pull the trigger. I am not convinced that Halladay is a top 10 SP anymore at which point you need to get a better hitter in return than the ones you mentioned.