Which of these deals makes more sense for me? I feel like I give up less in deal A, but I really would like to have a replacement OF for Rasmus and would need to clear a roster spot for Pedroia anyway.
Deal A: My Fielder and Rasmus for his Votto and Hosmer (1B)
Deal B: My Fielder, Rasmus and Moustakas for his Votto and Dunn (1B/OF)
12 Team H2H DAILY LEAGUE with 6 Keepers Season to Season, each for 3 years max. * means a keeper entering this season Stat Categories: R, 1B, 2B, 3B, HR, RBI, SB, BB, AVG -- IP, CG, W, L, ER, ERA, K, SV, WHIP
MY CURRENT TEAM
C Salvador Perez 1B Prince Fielder* 2B Jose Altuve 3B Miguel Cabrera* SS Hanley Ramirez* OF Ryan Braun* OF Jacoby Ellsbury OF Adrian Gonzalez UT David Ortiz UT Colby Rasmus UT Mike Moustakas BN Mike Napoli BN Emilio Bonifacio BN Carl Crawford DL Giancarlo Stanton DL Dustin Pedroia (Returning 7/19 - need to drop someone or clear a roster spot via trade)
SP Clayton Kershaw SP Cole Hamels SP Roy Halladay RP Craig Kimbrel RP Aroldis Chapman P CC Sabathia P Zack Greinke P Chris Sale BN Tommy Hanson BN Tim Lincecum
I do like Votto over Fielder, so win win there, But Rasmus doesn't look like he is slowing down at all. Hosmer has been a big dissapointment and it doesn't seem like he will bust out tell 2013 now, BUT since you only keep 6 guys doubt that Hosmer fits in your 6 keepers for next year if you do Deal-A
Maybe the pros of Votto will make Deal-A worth your while tho, I notch him above Prince in my opinion,
Definitely prefer A, as I think Hosmer is going to be better than Dunn the second half. Dunn has more value here than most leagues because batter Ks are not held against you. But I don't see throwing in Moose as making up the potential difference between Hosmer and Dunn. Maybe throw in Bonifacio since he's likely your cut when Pedroia comes back.