Dilemma between two Blockbusters. Need help ASAP!

[tommo]

12 Team H2H Weekly Points league. Scoring heavily favors pitching in the league. I have two offers on the table right now:

My Upton, Reyes, Hughes for Kershaw and Bonifacio. Or Reyes for Halladay. Which do you guys like best?

My Team
C Montero, Miguel ARI
1B Hosmer, Eric(1B) KC
2B Utley, Chase(2B) PHI
3B Lawrie, Brett(3B) TOR
SS Reyes, Jose(SS) MIA
OF Braun, Ryan(OF) MIL
OF Trout, Mike(OF) LAA
OF Upton, Justin(OF) ARI
U Butler, Billy(U) KC

Bench (OF) Craig, Allen(OF) STL
Bench (SS) Ramirez, Alexi (SS) CHW
Bench (OF) Cespedes, Yoenis(OF) OAK
Bench (1B) Rizzo, Anthony (1B) CHC

Bench (2B) Walker, Neil (2B) PIT

SP Garza, Matt(SP) CHC
SP Hudson, Tim(SP) ATL
SP Hughes, Phil(SP) NYY
RP Jansen, Kenleyr(RP) LAD
SP Greinke, Zach (P) MIL
SP Bumgarner, Madison(SP) SF
SP Fister, Doug (SP) DET
SP Parker, Jarrod (SP) OAK

Scoring System
Batting Categories
1B - Singles 1 points
2B - Doubles 2 points
3B - Triples 3 points
BB - Walks (Batters) 0.5 points
CS - Caught Stealing -1 point
CYC - Hitting for the Cycle 10 points
HP - Hit by Pitch 0.5 points
HR - Home Runs 4 points
KO - Strikeouts (Batter) -0.5 points
R - Runs 1 point
RBI - Runs Batted In 1 point
SB - Stolen Bases 1 point

Pitching Categories
BBI - Walks Issued (Pitchers) -0.5 points
BS - Blown Saves -4 points
CG - Complete Games 3 points
R - Earned Runs -1 point
HB - Hit Batsmen -0.5 points
INN - Innings 1.5 points
K - Strikeouts (Pitcher) 1 point
L - Losses -6 points
NH - No-Hitters 15 points
PG - Perfect Games 20 points
QS - Quality Starts 1 points
S - Saves 4 points
W - Wins 6 points

[handyman01]

I'd take the Reyes for Halladay deal. Hopefully the time off helped him heal up and he'll return to his usual form, in which case this would be an absolute steal.

[MattyG A's]

Honestly either one. With the first trade tho, you can eventually slide Bonifacio in to replace Reyes. You can put Allen Craig off your bench to replace and extremely lackluster/average Justin Upton. And You get Kershaws arm?? All of that sounds good to me.

[LittleTree]

I would go for Halladay as well. You would have had no chance to get Halladay the previous 4 years for that price. Plus, I think you need the help on your SP. Hope this helps.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=450404