Keeper Trade

[MrJB]

Hi guys, ive been following around here for a while and decided to join and get some opinion and hopefully share mine too!

So im in a point based h2h 4 player keeper. my team is out so im selling off for next year and collecting picks and some good keepers. here is a trade i have on the table..

Give: Ian Kennedy(12rnd)/Swisher(8th)

Get: Wade Miley (23rd)/Drew Smyly(23rd)

Plus a 16th rnd pick for my 23rd

also i have pinedea who i will be keeping.

Looking forward to some ideas!!!

Thanks,
JB

[MrJB]

this is also 14 team and keepers on a 3 year contract, Wins are +10 loss are -10.

[MadDog36]

If you can only keep four meh well that's only shaky but great value I might do it.

[MrJB]

think i should do a one for one...

Kennedy for Smyly or Miley
plus i would get a 16 for 23 pick

since i have pinedea that will give me 2 question mark young pitchers instead of 3.

also whats the opinions or the two...prefer Smyly or Miley? i lean toward Smyly myself

[LARS929]

What does the rest of your team/keepers look like? I may do that simply for the draft pick improvement...Miley and Smyly are better keepers at those spots than Kennedy and Swisher, but will you even keep them?

[MrJB]

we keep 4 and i have pineda(23) and maybe willingham(16)...those are the only other worthy keepers

Swisher im not keeping but kennedy(12) i might.

there isnt much on the rest of my team, i bought in this league this season and im rebuilding...ive already have 3 2nd round picks next year and plan on trading prince for another top pick.

[mrose]

Not super high on Miley or Smyly as keepers. Could you get a bit better pick in this? Help me? viewtopic.php?t=450410

[MrJB]

thats what im working on....im not too familiar with either guy besides there #'s so i wanted to get some opions on the 2 of them,