Either of these too much for McCutchen? WHIR

[CubsFan4Life23]

I give: Andrus, Jones and Papelbon
I get McCutchen and Darvish

I give: Kipnis, Plouffe and Jones
I get: McCutchen and Darvish

Part of me wants to get rid of Adam Jones and try to upgrade since we only keep 6, but also a part of me thinks he is worth keeping for 2013...Right now I am only set on keeping Braun, Kemp, Miggy and Felix...Kipnis, Jones, Posey, and Rizzo are in the running for the 5th and 6th keepers...Thoughts?

10 Team H2H (5x5, OBP replaces AVG), keeper (we keep 6) Possible keeper have * by their name.
My team:
C- Posey*
1B - Miggy*
2B - Kipnis*
SS - Andrus
3B - Prado
OF - Kemp*
OF - Braun*
OF - AJones*
U - Pence
U - Rizzo
Bench - Ploufee
Bench - Bonifacio

Felix*/Bumgarner*/Hughes/ Fiers/Marcum/Dempster/Halladay
Clippard/Papelbon/Kimbrel/Jansseen

[fish72292]

I would probably do either just because McCutchen is a definite keeper. Jones is a definite keeper though too if you hold on to him I just think McCutchen is better now and will be better in the future. Plus Darvish is only 25 and young himself getting him for Andrus and Papelbon (Especially with all your closers) leads me to think the 1st trade is better. Tough to do and give up Jones cause I love the guy. Either way I think you are getting the better end of the deal because you are getting McCutchen.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=450296