Trade Hosmer

[millerpark]

I have been offered:
B.J. Upton
(TB - CF)

Bryan LaHair
(ChC - 1B,LF,RF)

FOR

Eric Hosmer
(KC 1B)

What would you do...

My Roster:

C Buster Posey
(SF - C,1B)

1B Eric Hosmer
(KC - 1B)

2B Michael Cuddyer
(Col - 1B,2B,RF)

3B Drew Sutton
(PIT 3B,LF)

SS Jed Lowrie
(Hou - 3B,SS)

LF Josh Willingham
(Min - LF)

CF Drew Stubbs


RF Corey Hart
(Mil - 1B,RF)

Util Jim Thome
(Bal - Util)

Util Delmon Young
(Det - LF)


BN
Ty Wigginton
(Phi - 1B,3B,LF,RF)


Sean Rodriguez
(TB - 2B,3B,SS)

Justin Ruggiano
(Mia - LF,CF)

Luis Valbuena
(ChC - 2B,3B)

Rafael Furcal
(StL - SS)

Chris Davis
(Bal - 1B,3B,RF)

[dooho]

usually i don't like trades where i give my dime for 2 nickels. in this case i think you need some depth - though i would think you could get a little bit more though for hosmer. i personally probably wouldn't do this, i'd want more believing that hosmer's upside is worth more than those 2. but if you thought you needed bodies (thome?!?) then i wouldn't argue with you doing it.