So this story goes back a couple of months. In my main league, 12 team H2H points keeper, I was looking for a pitcher when I just broke in. The commissioner, who is a really nice guy, said he'd trade me Anibal Sanchez for Chris Sale and Austin Jackson. Sale was just about to return to starting, so I thought it was overpay. However, he argued that both guys had earned around the same amount of points so far as Anibal Sanchez. I accepted the agreement thinking I got the better end of the deal anyway.
Fast forward about a month and a half later, and my team, while in a bad division, has began to sunk. Anibal's destructive cold streak lost me a week I should have easily won and now my pitching continues to underperform. Feeling desperate, I asked the guy again if he'd be willing to trade. I was targeting James McDonald, because I didn't need another ace (I have Felix, Wainwright, and Darvish), I just needed someone who I could start for some quality innings and maybe reinvigorate my team. I had a surplus of pitching that went down the drain thanks to injuries to Cashner and Pettitte. I just needed one more quality guy. I decided to offer him Starlin Castro and Yoenis Cespedes for J-Mac, Alexei Ramirez and Carl crawford (I didn't have a great SS after Castro and I figured it would be more fair if I asked for Carwford as well since it is a keeper league). However, he rejected and and told me that was overpay since McD had given him more than 300 points. He completely disregarded any value Castro had as a keeper and stated that he wouldn't even give me Castro straight up for Carwford due to the points thing. He then offered me J-Mac and Alexei for Castro AND Yu Darvish. I politely said no and broke off the trade talks. Now, he seems like a nice enough guy and even is allowing a friend of mine to join our league if a team clears out. However, I feel he ripped me off the first time with this points stuff and tried to do it again this time.
So, is this a legit way to trade? Am I wrong to avoid trading with this guy from now on? What do you guys think?
A Fleshner Fantasy wrote:I don't see the problem. The guy is trying to talk his way into a better deal. Seems very standard to me. No matter how "nice a guy he is," he's trying to help his team, not yours.
No, I acknowledge the fact he's trying to get a better deal, I just find it very weird. No one else in my league does this. I've actually never seen this before.
In Points leagues, this is often a method used by owners to try and turn perceived value into what they want it to be amongst trade partners. The reality is that all that matters is how many points the respective players will accumulate from today forward. You have a keeper wrinkle attached to your league, as well. This owner sounds like somebody who may be difficult to deal with. They exist in every league. Nothing wrong with it. Move forward.
Yeah, sorry. Nothing wrong here. Nice enough leaguemate, sure, but he IS your competition. Today, I picked up Ruggiano in a league that i didn't need an outfielder in simply to block the Stanton owner from picking him up.
LightItUp95 wrote: However, I feel he ripped me off the first time with this points stuff and tried to do it again this time. So, is this a legit way to trade? ?
wait the other guy made a trade that improved his team, with an owner who may not have done his due diligence, and you want to know if its a "legit way to trade"? of course this is a legit way to trade.
nobody forced either party to make the deal. he did not rip you off. some owners are just better at projecting how players will perform over the rest of the season, and know how to manipulate other less experienced and/or less knowledgeable owners.
LightItUp95 wrote: Am I wrong to avoid trading with this guy from now on? What do you guys think?
if you dont feel comfortable dealing with, or dont think you can make a trade that improves your team then by all means avoid trading with him. but i would definitely not make that decision just because you feel ripped off after the fact. i mean you even said "I accepted the agreement thinking I got the better end of the deal anyway. "
Thursday wrote:Yeah, sorry. Nothing wrong here. Nice enough leaguemate, sure, but he IS your competition. Today, I picked up Ruggiano in a league that i didn't need an outfielder in simply to block the Stanton owner from picking him up.
I actually did the same exact thing today. No, when I said legit, i didn't mean illegal or wrong, I meant if it was a way of manioulating opponents. So is this common in points leagues? I've only played in Catergory leagues in the past so IDK.
Its common thing to do in any fantasy league. You gotta do whatcha gotta do right? He's trying to get maximum value out of the trade, and just because you feel you got ripped off the first time you shouldn't disregard him as a trading partner because in a league with like 12 teams you dont have alot of trading partners and the players to pick up via free agency are limited for fantasy numbers. Just don't think about him as a "nice guy" he might be the nicest guy but just think of him as an opponent when doing any trading or anything. Hope that helped a bit