Give Rodney, Get Floyd WHIR

[baegames]

I have a 20 save lead in an AL Only league but need strikeouts.

Do I give Fernando Rodney, get Gavin Floyd?

He offered Floyd for Tom Wilhelmsen, I responded Matt Capps for Floyd. Do I offer Rodney?

So my reason for wanting Wilhelmsen over Rodney is twofold: (1) I am afraid Rodney will fall to earth soon. (2) Wilhelmsen is more likely to be the closer next year, and a better keeper.

Maybe offer Rodney for Floyd and something else?

[fish72292]

I would take the Wilhelmsen one that he offered you. Rodney is better then him.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=450117

[xxxtheizxxx]

I have both of those RPs and I would take the first offer if you really want Floyd.
I'm a White Sox fan and I personally wouldn't want Floyd on my team. As for Rodney,
the guy has an ERA of like 0.98. There's no way I would trade him off especially for Floyd.

Help Please: viewtopic.php?f=26&t=450133&p=3545364#p3545364

[zyzzbrah34]

I would pass on Floyd altogether, but if you really want him, give Wilhelmsen instead of Rodney.

[sigriffey]

Can't help but feel Rodney should fetch more than Floyd. Try Wilhelmson first.

[baegames]

It sounds like people think I should get more for Rodney or Wilhelmsen than Floyd, is that correct?

[kingstar]

yeah, i also think you could get more for them floyd seems to only get about 4-5 K per start also has a career 4.06 second half ERA

help with mine viewtopic.php?f=26&t=450124