Castro+ for McDonald+? Help! WHIR 100%

[LightItUp95]

12 Team H2H keeper league. Castro isn't one of my keepers. I need one more starter. The guy I am discussing with has Sale, McDonald, Halladay, and Morrow. Who should i target and why, and is Starlin overpay for any of these guys?

Thanks, WHIR 100% Need quick help.

[fish72292]

I would want Halladay for Castro... but that is cause I have huge trust in him returning to form when he comes back and not everyone thinks that. Out of those other guys I would want Mcdonald cause Sale has that innings limit. Who else do you have to play short?

Help:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=450117

[FinZone]

Thx for your feedback.


Its kinda tough but Sale and McDonald if you can...but really don't know

[bobnerns]

Straight up for Castro, I would only take Halladay out of that list. I'd consider Sale+McDonald for Castro, but certainly not just one of them (and only if you have a reasonable replacement at SS).

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=450120

[RyeWhiskey]

I'd feel comfortable dealing Castro for Halladay assuming that I had a respectable backup.