Should I immediately cancel this trade offer...

[FinZone]

Am I in wrong for just now offering Nelson Cruz for Melky Cabrera??? I feel more production will come from Melky after All-Star break and in my Rotissere league I need help in the stolen base department.


Should I cancel?!?

[LightItUp95]

No, perfectly reasonable trade. You actually get the better half. Help?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=450123

[bobnerns]

I would prefer Cruz's upside to Melky because Melky is essentially at his absolute ceiling right now. He can't get much better whereas Cruz has always had top-10 potential.

There's a definite chance Melky has a better 2nd half than Cruz, but I'd be sticking with Cruz's upside.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=450120

[LightItUp95]

I would prefer Cruz's upside to Melky because Melky is essentially at his absolute ceiling right now. He can't get much better whereas Cruz has always had top-10 potential.

There's a definite chance Melky has a better 2nd half than Cruz, but I'd be sticking with Cruz's upside.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=450120

Cruz is streaky and he's start a steady decline over the last couple of years. Plus, Melky is actually healthy.

[RyeWhiskey]

I think the trade is fair and I like the Melky side of the deal.