My Holliday/Napoli for Hamilton/Garza

[murphydog]

Keeper league where Holliday cannot be kept again but Hamilton and the rest can. I have some catching depth so I think it works for me but wondering if Garza really adds anything to my team.Here's my squad...

Napoli
J.Montero
S. Perez
Votto
Altuve
Andrus
Zimmerman
Freese
Cespedes
Holliday
Trout
Trumbo

Chapman
Jansen
Axford
Whilhelmsen
Cueto
Strasburg
Peavy Oswalt
E. Jackson
W. Rodriguez
Kuroda

DL- Marcum, Morrow

[WaCougMBS]

If you're going to lose Holliday I'd do this deal. If not, I'd do this deal. Hamilton is not without risk, but the fact you get him locked up for at least another year and get an SP who's useful/helpful in the Ks department and won't kill your rations makes it a no-brainer for me. Montero has no business in your lineup right now, but a healthy Perez should be nice production, Hamilton should be better than Holliday ROS (he'll get hot again, don't worry) and Garza will help more than EJack and Rodriguez more often than not if nothing else

[MaudDib]

I do the deal. Garza is a solid pitcher and becomes even more solid after the trade deadline. Hamilton though is the big prize here.

[murphydog]

Garza's road numbers have me worried. Obviously Hamilton is a stud but Holliday is putting up major numbers and Napoli is due to get hot. Maybe I just need to be talked into this. Thanks for the replies.

[kool38]

I like the deal for you. Hamilton and Garza are great additions to your roster. Hamilton is what he is...when he plays=outstanding numbers. As for Garza, I like him better than a couple of your SPs already.
Holiday is solid but if you're losing him after the season, you solidified you Keepers by doing this trade.
I've never been a fan of Napoli...too much hype.



http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=449995