Kipnis or Pedroia for the rest of the way?

[choan15]

in a 11 team head to head league.

Who would you rather have for the rest of the way?
Jason Kipnis or Dustin Pedroia??

[Skimo77]

Pedroia's thumb worries me, and Kipnis looks pretty legit so he gets my vote... but maybe i overvalue him...

[Quackman]

i think it will be close. Kipnis is a 5 stat guy but pedroia could have great production with Crawford and Ellsbury coming back. Also he seems to be heating up so maybe the thumb is a non-issue. Still tough to say i wouldnt take Kipnis. I think it will closer than i looks right now.

[MadDog36]

You want an injured stud in Pedroia or a healthy Kinsler Jr easy decision.

[jfg]

Kipnis might be the better player anyway even if Pedroia wasn't injured. Pedroia's MVP season compared to Kipnis this year:

HR- About even
Avg- Pedroia by a lot
Runs- Pedroia by a hair
RBI- Kipnis by a hair
SB- Kipnis by a lot

So, it depends if you need more help with average or stolen bases... and this is going off Pedroia's MVP season. I think it's pretty safe to say that this year, Kipnis is easily the better player.

[redkanefox2009]

I own Kipnis and I wouldn't give him up for anything, he's having a great year and I would pick him the rest of the way.

Help with mine please? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449934

[Junse19]

Kipnis is awesome. He gets hits, stolen bases, hits for power, and is a good fielder. I have him in a keeper league for $3. I'll basically have him on my roster for his entire career.

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=449924