Kinsler for Hanley Ramirez? would you do it....WHIR

[slick56]

Yahoo league h2h im in 2nd in my division. I was just offered Hanley Ramirez for my Kinsler.
I made some moves and got my team where i like it. However I am not sure if 1 more trade is good for me or not. I am banking on Lawrie doing pretty well and Plouffe as my only 3b options.

Here is my team? would you do this with Kipnis as your other 2b?



Starters:
C: Wieters 1b: Dunn 2b: Kinsler SS: ACabrera 3b: Lawrie OF: Adam Jones OF: McCutchen OF: JReddick Uti: ARios Uti: Kipnis.
SP: Gallardo, Wainwright, JSantana, Gio Gonzalez, JShields RP: Kimbrel, KJansen, Myers, Hanarahan, JBenoit.

Bench: Austin Jackson, Kemp, Plouffe.
TBauer, JParker, Liriano.

[kaiser]

I can'r believe I'm saying it, but no, I would stick with Kinsler. Hanley is just not the Hanley of old. I traded him away in a deal for Pujols earlier this season, while he was hot for a brief time, and I am glad I did.

[wazzeus]

Nope. Kinsler is more valuable at 2B than Hanley is at 3B.

[fish72292]

Agreed with everyone else. Kinsler is too valuable at 2b.

Help with mine:
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449798

[MadDog36]

Sit tight.

[redkanefox2009]

Same as everyone else, I would stick with Kinsler, wouldn't want HanRam on my team right now.

Help with mine please? viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449934

[Junse19]

Does Hanley have SS eligibility in your league?

Help with mine? viewtopic.php?t=449924

[bobnerns]

You've got enough flexibility to make their positions not really matter in this deal. So just comparing Kinsler to Hanley rest of season, I'd probably stick with Kinsler. He's in a much better offense, in a much better park, and a much easier division. Aside from those aspects, they are pretty close so I'd give the edge to Kinsler.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449936&p=3544032#p3544032