Big Trade...Kershaw for CarGo...WHIR

[CDAG02]

I've been offered Kershaw for CarGo. I really need SP but hate to lose a bat like CarGo. Is this a good deal for me? Can I afford to lose a bat like that or should I go after someone like Greinke/Cliff Lee with Upton?

H2H, 10 player keeper league, 11x11 standard categories

C-Yadier Molina
1B-Adrian Gonzalez
2B-Ian Kinsler
SS-Jose Reyes
3B-Edwin Encarnacion
INF-Billy Butler
OF-Giancarlo Stanton
OF-Justin Upton
OF-Curtis Granderson
UTIL-Carlos Gonzalez
UTIL-Allen Craig
BN-Alex Rodriquez
BN-Lucas Duda
BN-Wil Myers
DL-Matt Kemp

SP-CC Sabathia
SP-Felix Hernandez
SP-Edwin Jackson
RP-Addison Reed
RP-Ernesto Frieri
RP-David Hernandez
P-Ryan Vogelsong
P-Mike Leake
P-Ricky Romero
P-Ricky Nolasco
P-Trevor Bauer

[11stever11]

I would hang onto Cargo. A valuable bat is better than a valuable pitcher. I think Upton for Lee or Greinke is closer but I would still hang tight.
help me please?
viewtopic.php?t=449868

[germani40]

Pitchers are a lot riskier. TJ can come at any point hitters dont have a devastating injury like that to a career. Hitters are always the safer bet. Keep Cargo



viewtopic.php?f=26&t=449875

[lane_anasazi2]

Cargo.

[fish72292]

I would want to keep Cargo in this deal... maybe try and use Upton if you really want a top tier pitcher.

help with mine:
viewtopic.php?t=449914

[jfg]

I don't know if this as open and shut as people are saying. When Kemp comes back you'll have to move Craig to the bench. That's throwing away stats when you have weaknesses at pitcher. I think I'd make this trade, I'm in a similar situation in my league where my offense is stacked and I'm leaving a lot of stats on the bench and can't find anybody who will give up a Kershaw, Verlander or Strasburg for my Cabrera or Bautista. Honestly, I think I'd take this trade.

[MadDog36]

You have the depth with Kemp, Craig and even Arod. I would look to snag another arm but not one quite as dominant as Kershaw. You have a good staff. I wouldn't shoot for the moon. Try to get a lesser quality but good SP instead.

Upton for Greinke or even Kersh I'd sign off on that. Not Lee, his team just is in shambles and even at full strength not enough trust there.