Snag Ellsbury?

[stlcards02]

So I'm in a 20-team keeper pts league. I've done a few trades to start consolidating as their are a few teams that have put themselves ahead of the pack talent wise. So I'm semi-looking towards next year. We keep 8 with no restrictions. I have a team looking to contend and needs some more pitching, he had interest in a trade like this. Just wanted to gauge some reactions to it. Pts to date in (_) Teams like to run out as many starters as possible, so trades tend to be skewed in that manor. Thoughts?

Give: Shields(280), Butler(293), Richard(268)
Get: Ellsbury(na), CBYoung(139)

C Jesus Montero
1B Edwin Encarnacion
2B Chris Nelson
3B Will Middlebrooks
SS Elvis Andrus
OF Matt Holiday
OF Franklin Gutierrez
OF Adam Jones
UT Everth Cabrera
UT Billy Butler
BN Leonys Martin
BN Nolan Arenado
DL Evan Longoria

P Clayton Kershaw
P James Shileds
P Dillon Gee
P Clayton Richard
P Yu Darvish
BN Wei-Yin Chen
BN Carlos Villanueva
BN Joe Kelly
BN Justin Grimm
BN Jake Odorizzi
DL Jeff Niemann

[wazzeus]

Franklin Gutierrez is in your outfield and you're asking if you should pick up one of the best players on the planet, the guy who by rights should have been the AL MVP last year?