Would you rather have Gallardo or Haren?

[siugrad30]

With Utley coming off the DL, I need to drop a player. So, I'm looking to make a 2-for-1 deal with a team.

Would you 1) want Gallardo or Haren?

And two be OK with a trade of Choo/Hudson or Choo/Lynn for either of them?

Thanks

[Element]

Gallardo has a history of being a 2nd half performer whereas Haren as a history of being a 2nd half disaster. I like Haren more as a pitcher, but with his velocity down & the proof in the numbers I would rather have Gallardo moving forward.