middlebrooks/de aza for peavy? whir

[fierro33]

should i give up

de aza
middlebrooks

for

peavy


i need to clear up a roster space and might be dropping de aza anyways


shallow 10 team non keeper h2h 5x5

C Yadier Molina
1B Joey Votto
2B Kelly Johnson
3B Miguel Cabrera
SS Dee Gordon
OF Justin Upton
OF Michael Bourne
OF Josh Willingham
Util Prince Fielder
Miguel Montero
Alejando De Aza
Will Middlebrooks
Anthony Rizzo
Colby Rasmus
Paul Goldschmidt


Justin Verlander
Cliff Lee
Jered Weaver
Zach Greinke
Madison Bumgarner
Matt Moore

Jonathon Papelbon
Ernesto Frieri

[WaCougMBS]

Your pitching is already really solid, but you are also overloaded with corner infielders, so yeah I think I'd do it. Considering you were going to drop AdA anyway, you might as well snag Peavy and pray for 3 more healthy months. Might want to try to package some of that CI depth and an OF for upgrades at either SS or that Willingham OF spot - lots of value on the bench, I have to think there's some deals out there for you to upgrade your starting group as much as possible. Hope this helps

[wazzeus]

Peavy is a huge injury risk. Middlebrooks' middle name is "Upside," and De Aza has been valuable ... I think you'd be giving up too much, frankly.

[Thursday]

While i also agree that you're giving up too much, i think it's not bad - bench players that aren't doing much for you and won't crack the lineup for a guy that can go every 5th day. I think it'd pull the trigger, but ultimately up to you - do you like the hitting depth, or do you want one more starter?

Help out?

http://www.fantasybaseballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=449596

[lane_anasazi2]

I like having more bench SP as opposed to hitters. You're taking a risk, but I'd probably do it.