Votto Deal

[oriolemagic33]

Standard 12-team NON-keeper H2H

C: J Montero
1B: Butler, Davis
2B: Aviles, R Weeks
SS: Hardy
3B: Freese, Plouffe
OF: CarGo
OF: Stanton
OF: Rasmus, Pagan
DL: Kemp

SP: Sale, Bumgarner, C Lewis, Miley, Lester, Samardzija
RP: Jansen, Motte, Axford
DL: Hellickson

I have been offered Votto, Starlin Castro, CJ Wilson, and Bryan LaHair for my CarGo, Stanton, Aviles, and Bumgarner.

Should I take this deal? My offense has been slumping so I am eager to grab bats. Any suggestions for counter-offers would be GREATLY appreciated. His other players I'd be interested in are Bourn and N Cruz. I'd ultimately like to get Votto and Castro without giving up CarGo, so I'm willing to give up some pitching.

Post a link and I definitely WHIR!

[fierro33]

i dont think i would do that deal....cargo is a monster this year. I would keep him. Dont worry about tryin to get castro. Try to get votto at all costs without having to give up cargo. Then worry about SS later as the SS position really isnt that important. Castro is not a difference maker

[Quackman]

Lahair doesnt help you, i would also try and keep cargo. id throw kemp in there before cargo. Kemp wont be stealing alot of bases even if he remains healthy.

[brila777]

Dont like it, all your players are better. THe deal comes down to cargo and votto and i guess thats the choice you need to make.

Help viewtopic.php?t=449440

[oriolemagic33]

Any ideas for counter-offers?

[Seanyfever]

I am also not in favor of this.... Tell him there is something just mot right... Can we do something differently. See what he comes back with.... Cargo is tje player to get out of this deal.


Help out a Cafe Brother.
viewtopic.php?t=449417

[baegames]

I'd pass. I don't like this deal for you at all.