whos the better keeper?

[ratking20]

hosmer or posey??????

[WaCougMBS]

hosmer or posey??????

I think it's Hos in a vacuum, but it's kinda close. What are your league specs, roster size, other keepers, etc.?

[Carnac]

I like Hosmer as a keeper over Buster. Hosmer should develope more power over the next couple of years.

Help? viewtopic.php?t=449403

[ratking20]

anyone else?

[Jase44]

I have both and at the end of the year if I have to choose I probably take Posey just because of position scarcity. Depends on the make of your league but 1B can usually be drafted easier than a C. Plus the gap in C from top tier to 2nd tier is larger than at 1B. Just look at Ortiz, Encaracion, Trumbo, Dunn, Butler, Goldy. Easier shoes to fill there, stick with Posey

[converge241]

I think even with his bad year so far and the position thing, I think I still lean Hosmer. But this is a tough call could easily see the case for Posey

viewtopic.php?t=449561